How To Identify A Synthetic / Adulterated Vinegar ?

How to spot a natural vinegar?. I wrote this previous article because of the proliferation of synthetic vinegar.

My uncle was buying vinegar. The vinegar gallon was got empty. He thought the store was really got out of stock  but one boy grabbed the gallon and told him to wait. This boy went to nearby deep well and filled the container with water.  Then boy carried back the gallon to store and voila! The vinegar was coming out of the water container.  This was a sure synthetic vinegar. acetic acid molecule

A friend of mine stopped by a sidewalk vendor who was selling vinegar in 1.5 L softdrink PET bottles. She was going to buy cause she taught it was a natural vinegar from sugar palm, kaong. She asked the vendor if the vinegar was pure, not adulterated with synthetic version. Vendor honestly replied that it was a mixture of natural and synthetic. My friend got disappointed and never bought any.

Telling weather the vinegar is synthetic or natural can be hard especially for branded products.  Natural vinegar cloudiness disappears after few weeks or months of storage but what if the manufacturer is also producing the clear version. Identifying the difference is hard.

Vinegar can be obtained through the following processes:

1) destructive distillation of wood

2) oxidation of acetylene and water by air

3) oxidation of ethyl alcohol by aerobic bacteria, as in the production of vinegar

Natural vinegars are from method 1 and 3, method number 2 is obviously synthetic. Method 1 produces wood vinegar but not widely used for food applications due to methanol content.

Philippine Nuclear Research Institute developed the first test for adulteration of vinegar with synthetic glacial acetic acid, the carbon-14 analysis by liquid scintillation spectrometry. Out of 10 popular brands tested, 56% were adulterated. The extent of adulteration can also be determined.

I hope they can reveal which brands are adulterated and which are pure. This will be a great benefit to consumers.

Marvin is the lead chocolate maker of Ben and Lyn Chocolate Inc. Has strong background in food research and development. Occasionally conducts training and lectures. Lecturer of Cocoa Foundation of the Philippines. Do coaching and consultancy services on his free time.

3 Replies to “How To Identify A Synthetic / Adulterated Vinegar ?”

  1. PNRI MUST reveal if not published the 56
    % adulterated vinegar brands. It is mandated upon them to report at least since these brands are mislabeled and are fooling the consumers. Besides it it hazardous to our health their continued selling of these adulterated brands. So what is this PNRi doing? Isn’t it they( PNRI-a gov’t entity) exists because of people’s money? If they can’t do this, as least what they can do is report to the proper agencies like BFAD or DOH. Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.